Top News, Articles, and Interviews in Philosophy

Proof and the Virtues of Shared Enquiry†

Philosophy News image
ABSTRACTThis paper investigates an important aspect of mathematical practice: that proof is required for a finished piece of mathematics. If follows that non-deductive arguments — however convincing — are never sufficient. I explore four aspects of mathematical research that have facilitated the impressive success of the discipline. These I call the ‘Practical Virtues’: Permanence, Reliability, Autonomy, and Consensus (PRAC). I then argue that permitting results to become established on the basis of non-deductive evidence alone would lead to their deterioration (with some possible exceptions). This furnishes us with a partial rational justification for mathematicians’ strict insistence on proof.

Continue reading . . .

News source: Philosophia Mathematica Current Issue

blog comments powered by Disqus

Recent Books in Philosophy


Check out some of the latest books being published in philosophy
in various fields and disciplines.