Deanonymizing self-references after review?




In our newest “how can we help you?” thread, a reader asks:

When my draft undergoes a refereeing process, I follow the norm in referring to my own past papers as if they were written by another person. My question is this: when I de-anonymize my draft, is it appropriate if I (1) delete some self-references where I repeat some of my past points, to the effect that I refer to myself a bit less that I would if it were a different author; (2) use the first-person pronoun whenever referring to myself if applicable? Other suggestions for de-anonymizing are also welcome!

Good questions. I’m not entirely sure about (1), as deleting a bunch of in-text citations (even if they are to oneself) seem like substantive changes to the draft that was refereed. (2) seems entirely fine to me. What do you all think?

Originally appeared on The Philosophers’ Cocoon Read More



Cosmological Argument

[Revised entry by Bruce Reichenbach on June 30, 2022. Changes to: Main text, Bibliography] The cosmological argument is less a...