Search
Search
Brain vs Heart: a false dichotomy
Brain vs Heart: a false dichotomy

Date

source

share

Within Western thought, cognition and emotion have traditionally been conceived as adversaries. Thomas Dixon debunks this reason/feeling dichotomy and its historical connection with patriarchal ideas. “Your emotions are valid”. So runs a popular slogan, often seen in mental-health memes and . . .

Within Western thought, cognition and emotion have traditionally been conceived as adversaries. Thomas Dixon debunks this reason/feeling dichotomy and its historical connection with patriarchal ideas.
 
“Your emotions are valid”. So runs a popular slogan, often seen in mental-health memes and social media posts. I am never entirely sure what “valid” means in this context, but the word usually implies that something is reasonable, cogent, based in reality, or ethically valuable. Does that really apply to my emotions? All of them? And yours too? And the hateful emotions of racists, and misogynists? And the irrational terrors of painfully deluded conspiracy theorists? Surely not.
Of course, most people’s views about human emotions are more nuanced than just saying they are all “valid”. And the intention behind the slogan – helping people to accept their feelings rather than demonising or pathologising them – is a wholesome one. Nonetheless, in…

Read the full article which is published on IAI TV (external link)

More
articles

More
news

What is Disagreement?

What is Disagreement?

This is Part 1 of a 4-part series on the academic, and specifically philosophical study of disagreement. In this series...

Skolem’s Paradox

Skolem’s Paradox

[Revised entry by Timothy Bays on February 5, 2025. Changes to: Main text, notes.html] Skolem’s Paradox involves a seeming conflict...

Philosophy of Psychiatry

Philosophy of Psychiatry

[Revised entry by Dominic Murphy on February 5, 2025. Changes to: Main text, Bibliography] Philosophical discussions of mental disorder fall...

A Graduate Student’s Nightmare

A Graduate Student’s Nightmare

Those who supervise or assess dissertations should recognize that the power they exercise is easily abused and can result in...

Relational Quantum Mechanics

Relational Quantum Mechanics

[Revised entry by Carlo Rovelli on February 4, 2025. Changes to: Main text, Bibliography] Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM) is the...