Search
Search
Httpssubstack post media s3 amazonaws compublicimagesd38a028b abdb 440e 8530 6f45ba28855a 2000x1139
The Central Paradox of Stoicism
date
author
share

This post was originally published on this site.

Hieronymus Bosch, The Garden of Earthly Delights, c. 1495–1505 (Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons). Bosch’s panorama gives us a vision of early life as a choice between good and evil and the consequences — on the far right — for choosing the latter. But older (and some Christian) traditions ask, is evil really a choice people make?

Throughout our lives we live by the rubric of principles we’ve absorbed, inherited, or deliberately embraced. We consider these ideas foundational. We follow their direction in our plans and our actions, they guide us through our ups and downs.

But occasionally these foundational ideas come to a point where they collide. This leaves us flummoxed — do we disregard one idea and follow another? Do we reconsider all our beliefs altogether? It can lead to private crisis.

The central paradox within Stoicism is one that even Stoics struggle with. It’s ignored for the most part in modern Stoic literature. Embedded within the ancient Stoic texts, there’s a black hole that threatens to break Stoicism’s internal coherence.

On the one hand, we possess a faculty of choice. It is so fundamental that it cannot be touched by circumstance or coercion. And yet, there is another idea within Stoicism, an idea that is no less insistent and forceful. When somebody commits a wrong, they are not to blame. The Stoics tell us not to punish them.

The first idea is what Stoics call prohairesis, we can translate this into modern English as “will”. It is in our power to judge, to assent to the impressions that flood through our consciousness, and to set actions in motion with our intentions.

These three faculties are ours alone, and, according to Epictetus, this tripartite structure is both the core of our being and where our absolute freedom lies. You can choose. You have moral agency. Always. This is a central force in Stoic thinking.

The second idea is that moral evil has no essence. Just as darkness is absence of light, and error is the absence of knowledge, moral evil is simply a mistake.

Everybody wants what is beneficial to them, but they become confused about what exactly is beneficial. This is ultimately an idea the Stoics inherited from Socrates. For Socrates there is no human good and evil, there is wisdom and ignorance. The good is the lodestar for all of us. Those who commit evils are simply mistaken about what is good.

It’s hard to think of good and evil in this way because for two thousand years, Western thinking has largely defined good and evil as two sides of a cosmic conflict manned by human souls.

In the Socratic view, evil is simply the absence of good, not a self-standing existing thing with an essence.

Marcus even quotes Socrates in Book 7 of the Meditations:

“‘No soul’, [Socrates] said, ‘is willingly deprived of the truth’; and the same applies to justice too, and temperance, and benevolence, and everything of the kind. It is most necessary that you should constantly keep this in mind, for you will then be gentler towards everyone.”

This seems strange — people are, after all, cruel, deceitful, lazy and so on. But somebody being deceitful to get a promotion, for example, is taking their own well-being to be more important to them than the well-being of the community.

If that person understood that the well-being of the community is paramount to the good of everybody — including themselves, and that fulfilling self-centered desires doesn’t make you truly happy, then they wouldn’t use deceit to get a promotion.

In the Discourses of Epictetus, this is made clear:

“Philosophers say that people are all guided by a single standard […] If all this is true, then what grounds do we have for being angry with anyone? We use labels like ‘thief’ and ‘robber’ in connection with them, but what do those words mean? They merely signify that people are confused about what is good and what is bad. So should we be angry with them, or should we pity them instead?” (Discourses 1.18)

Marcus repeats the idea at the start of his famous first paragraph of Book 2 of his Meditations.

“Say to yourself at the start of the day, I shall meet with meddling, ungrateful, violent, treacherous, envious, and unsociable people. They are subject to all these defects because they have no knowledge of good and bad”. (Meditations 2.1)

Those people, Marcus implies, are innocent because their thought is defective. In the Gregory Hays translation, the middle part is rendered as, “They are like this because they can’t tell good from evil” (My emphasis).

So we have the collision of two ideas:

  1. You are in absolute control of your judgements, your desires, and your intentions.

  2. You are ignorant when you commit a wrong.

It’s easy to see the questions that would arise from this paradox.

If somebody has full control over their beliefs, desires, and intentions, then how could they not be responsible for a crime they commit? If virtue is a matter of dispelling ignorance, then doesn’t luck play a role in becoming virtuous? If you’re ignorant, how can you climb out of ignorance, if your ignorance is what pulls you away from virtue?

How do we unravel this knot? How do we reconcile those two ideas? How can a person possess full control over their will, and yet be blind to what is good? How can you be wholly responsible for your choices and yet at the same time be blameless for your actions?

How We Solve a Paradox

We’re trapped between two seemingly impossible positions. Either the sinner had the power to choose correctly and failed to make use of it — and therefore deserves condemnation — or they were unable to know the difference between good and evil, which robs them of the agency — the will / prohairesis — that Stoicism takes as real.

Condemning evil in other people is in itself evil in the Stoic view of the world. Theft, violence, and insults affect only what the Stoics call “indifferents” — the externals of our property, our bodies, and our reputation — things that are neither good nor bad in themselves. We have no moral right, as far as Epictetus was concerned, to be displeased with these transgressions, let alone punish them. He wrote, “As long as you honour material things, direct your anger at yourself rather than the thief or adulterer.” (Discourses 1.18).

Epictetus is suggesting that while we cannot blame others for moral failings, we can blame ourselves. It’s clear in his own words that self-directed condemnation is permissible.

We can therefore say that Stoicism isn’t a moral system for the world — it’s a moral system for you.

The focus is inward, and the Stoic must be always watchful of moral lapses and errors that arise from misunderstanding their place in the Cosmos, and what is good in respect to that.

Other people’s ignorance may impinge on our lives, but we must handle those wrongdoings as we’d handle other externals such as natural and social evils like sickness, injury, and misfortune: with the Stoic “indifference”, choosing to see them as neither good nor bad, since only our own actions in response to them can be good or bad.

It is not incumbent on you to judge others; it’s incumbent on you to set an example to others, and to teach those who are willing to learn.

But if good is a matter of knowledge, how do we know that we’ve correctly identified the good?

Epictetus explains in the Enchiridion that “just as targets are not set up in order to be missed, so neither does the nature of evil exists in the world.” (27)

This metaphor can be interpreted as either relating to cosmology or the human condition. In the cosmological sense, Epictetus could be saying that we live in a providential universe that’s oriented toward the good. When we act badly, when we fail to be morally excellent, we “miss” the goals intended for us.

This reading may well be the one that Epictetus intended, but we can read it in another, more secular, sense that is just as compelling. We could say that all life aspires to what is good for it, and avoids what is bad.

Natural targets such as abundance, the greater good, love, and happiness, are “set up” within all of us. We strive and aim for what is good, and we miss when we misunderstand the good.

Against this background, we can see that agency and blamelessness are not in tension. The fault at stake here is a correctable error of understanding.

We all aspire to the good, but an insufficient understanding of what good is leads to moral evil. If I were to think that my own gratification at the cost of somebody else’s well-being were a good, I would simply be wrong about what is good — I’d be deficient in my understanding of the good. I’d miss the target set up for me.

But the targets for good are supplied by nature. They are enduringly there as surely as the ground beneath our feet. Nature has given us reason, and guides us with happiness, contentment, compassion, and love. We err from good, but it insistently waits for us.

Thank you for reading.

Subscribe now

More
articles

More
news

Astrobiology and the Limits of Life

Rossella Vingelli on the Limits of Life

Rossella Vingelli is a PhD candidate in Philosophy at the University of Liverpool, working on the philosophical conceptualisation of extraterrestrial...