Rossella Vingelli is a PhD candidate in Philosophy at the University of Liverpool, working on the philosophical conceptualisation of extraterrestrial life. She recently published the article “Astrobiology and the Limits of Life” on Daily Philosophy:

Rossella Vingelli: Astrobiology and the Limits of Life
The question of life stands at the very core of astrobiology, often defined as the study of the origin, evolution, distribution, and future of life in the universe.
Your article moves quite gracefully between hard science and philosophy. What drew you to astrobiology specifically as a philosopher rather than, say, as a biologist or physicist? Was there a particular moment or idea that made you feel this was your question?
I think my interest in astrobiology comes from the meeting of two fields of study that are often seen as quite separate: science and philosophy. Before studying philosophy at university, I attended a scientific high school, where I developed a strong inclination towards scientific thinking and
towards the way science observes, experiments, and seeks to understand the world. Later, I chose to study philosophy because I felt it would allow me to continue questioning existence in a critical way. And when I speak of existence, I simply mean everything that exists.
That has always been my understanding of philosophy: not as an abstract discipline, but as a way of understanding reality in its entirety. Over time, I realised that these two approaches were not in conflict at all, but deeply complementary. Science builds knowledge through observation, experimentation, and evidence, while philosophy reflects on the meaning of what we discover, on the limits of our knowledge, and on the role of human perception. Between these two perspectives there is another element that I
consider fundamental: intuition. I think intuition often forms the bridge between philosophical reflection and the scientific method. A new question usually begins with an intuition; philosophy develops it critically, and science then attempts to test and verify it.
For me, astrobiology is precisely where these different ways of thinking come together. It is a deeply scientific discipline, but at the same time an inevitably philosophical one.
You introduce “extended organicity” as the object of your own research. Could you tell us, in plain terms, what problem it was you felt existing definitions of life were failing to solve, and what first made you reach for a new concept?
During the development of my MPhil thesis, Human and Vegetal Life – an interdisciplinary project that brought together philosophy, botany, and architecture to reflect on the climate crisis and our relationship with nature and biodiversity – I began to realise that we tend to think of life as a property of the individual organism, whereas no organism truly exists in …