Steven Cassedy: What Do We Mean When We Talk About Meaning




Cassedy, S. (2022). What Do We Mean when We Talk about Meaning?. Oxford University Press. 216 pages. ISBN: 9780190936907.

The title of this book is misleading. Steven Cassedy’s concern is with ‘meaning’ in its most general sense, which he takes to be manifested in the history of discussion about the meaning and purpose of life. But there are many philosophical theories about meaning in its most general sense which, because they are not explicitly about the meaning of life, he does not mention.

However, with regard to the historical understanding of the meaning and purpose of life, significant new ground is broken – by virtue of the fact that the author has an impressive array of languages at his disposal, including Greek, Latin, Hebrew, German, Russian and Danish. The story begins with the Jewish scriptures and continues through ancient Greece. All the while – as the author makes clear – until the very end of the eighteenth century, the meaning of life is discussed only implicitly for it is not until Novalis and Friedrich Schlegel that the phrase ‘the meaning of life’ (der Sinn des Lebens) is explicitly mentioned and it is only then that it unambiguously takes on its modern meaning. It first enters the English language from the early romantics, via Thomas Carlyle.

Altogether this is the most comprehensive account of how the phrase ‘the meaning of life’ came to attain its current ubiquity that has yet been written. 

The author is very good at discussing the subtle differences and similarities of different senses of ‘meaning’ as found in different languages; and there are detailed discussions of Kierkegaard, Dostoyevsky, Tolstoy and Paul Tillich. Altogether this is the most comprehensive account of how the phrase ‘the meaning of life’ came to attain its current ubiquity that has yet been written.

However, inevitably there are some omissions. There is no mention of Nietzsche except for Paul Tillich’s reading of him, despite the fact that the prospect of a lack of life’s meaning was one of Nietzsche’s foremost preoccupations; there is no look further afield than the Hebrew tradition – no look, for example, at the Sanskrit texts translated by August Wilhelm von Schlegel; and no mention of nihilism. (On the parallel late eighteenth origins of nihilism see A Defence of Nihilism (2021) by James Tartaglia and Tracy Llanera. They describe ‘the meaning of life’ and ‘nihilism’ as the good and bad twins.)

James Tartaglia: Are You A Nihilist?

The terminology of ‘nihilism’ and ‘the meaning of life’ emerged among a small group of German philosophers at the end of the 18th century who were worried about the French Enlightenment.

A more general concern is whether something should have been said about the history of the definition of ‘life’. Admittedly, the question ‘what is the meaning / purpose of life?’ is conceptually distinct from the question ‘what is …

Originally appeared on Daily Philosophy Read More



The importance of doubting

by Massimo Pigliucci There is freedom of thought, and each one can sustain what he wants, as for me, I...

The danger of ethics without empathy

The relationship between morality and emotion has divided thinkers for centuries. Most contemporary ethical systems demand impartiality; that we should...